Manual vs Automated Stop Loss: Pros and Cons

Setting a manual vs automated stop loss is an important decision for day traders since you must make many quick decisions. One of the most important decisions you can make is how to manage your risk. Both have pros and cons, and it can be tough to determine which is right for you. This article will discuss the difference between manual and automated stop losses and help you decide which is best for your trading style and to limit losses.

There are many rules and strategies that day traders use to minimize their losses and protect their profits. One of the most critical aspects of risk management is setting a stop loss. A stop loss is an order you place with your broker to sell your position if it reaches a specific price. For long positions, this price is typically below the current market price to limit losses to your trading account if the market price falls. Stop losses are supported across multiple markets, like the stock, forex currency, and the futures commodity markets.

There are two overall kinds of stop losses – manual and automated. A manual stop loss is one that you set yourself, but your trading software or platform sets an automated stop loss. Most traders set stop losses based on technical analysis and price levels, like support and resistance, or at a specified amount the trader is willing to risk. 

Manual Stop Losses

Since the trader sets manual stop losses, they require manual intervention and management. This means that you, the trader, have complete control over your risk management. You can change your stop loss as you see fit, based on market conditions or your trading strategy. However, manual stop losses also require constant vigilance. You could lose more money than planned if you are not actively monitoring your trade.

Manual stop losses have a few advantages:

1. You have complete control over your stop loss price. You can set it at a level you are comfortable with, and you don’t have to worry about it being triggered by a sudden market move.
2. Manual stop losses allow you to change your stop loss price as the market moves, which can allow you to lock in profits or protect against a further decline.
3. Manual stop losses allow the trader to have more control over their trade.

There are also some disadvantages to manual stop losses:

1. It can be challenging to stick to your stop loss price if the market moves quickly.
2. Manual stop losses require you to constantly monitor the market to determine when to execute your stop loss. Continuously watching the market can be time-consuming and stressful, especially when you day trade full-time.
3. Manual stop losses are often based on emotion, leading to bad decision-making.

Automated Stop Losses

Automated stop loss orders are set using automated trading software or your trading platform. Once configured, they will automatically close out your position when it reaches a specific price point. These stop losses take the emotion out of decision-making and help you stick to your risk management plan. However, automated stop losses can also be subject to slippage. Slippage is when the market moves so quickly that your stop loss is not triggered at the exact price you set it for. This disconnect can lead to slight losses or even more significant losses if the market continues to move against you.

Automated stop losses have some advantages as well.

1.  First, they take the emotion out of the equation. If you set a manual stop loss, it can be challenging to stick to it if the market is moving against you. This situation can lead to impulsive decisions that can cost you money. However, your order will be executed automatically with an automated stop loss if the market price reaches your stop loss level. This keeps the trader with a disciplined mindset and focused without their emotions running rampant.
2. Automated stop losses can save you time. There is no requirement to consistently monitor the market to enter your stop loss quickly when the market moves against you.

There are some disadvantages to automated stop losses. 

1. First, you have less control over your stop loss price than manual stop losses. You must set your stop loss level based on risk tolerance and market volatility.
2. Second, if the stock drops quickly, you may not have enough time to adjust your stop loss before it is triggered.
3. Automated stop losses can sometimes prevent you from making a profit. If the market starts to move in your favor after your stop loss hit, you will miss out on any potential gains.

Manual vs Automated Stop Loss: Stop Loss Considerations

So, which type of stop loss should you use? Here are a few questions to take into consideration:

-Do you want more control over your stop loss?

-Do you mind if your stop loss is triggered by a slight price movement?

-Are you comfortable with your broker automatically selling your position?

A manual stop loss may be your best option if you want more control over your stop loss. You can choose where to place your order with a manual stop loss. You also can change your stop loss if you need to.

If you don’t mind if a slight price movement triggers your stop loss, then an automated stop loss may interest you. With an automated stop loss, you don’t have to worry about manually placing the order. Your broker will automatically sell your position if it reaches your set price.

If you’re not comfortable with your broker automatically selling your position, it may be best to go with a manual stop loss. With a manual stop loss, you can choose to cancel the order at any time. 

Remember, there is no right approach when choosing a manual or automated stop loss. It will depend on your personal trading style and what you prefer. So, remember to consider and think about what would work best for you. 

Summary: Manual vs Automated Stop Loss

Day trading can be a very profitable venture, but it is also risky. This is why day traders must figure out if a manual vs automated stop loss is needed. The number one way to lower risk is by setting a stop loss. There are two ways to do this: manual and automated. Automated stop losses may be better if you want a set-it-and-forget-it approach. No matter which you choose, make sure you understand the risks and rewards before making any decisions.

Want to learn more about day trading? Check out this webinar to watch our unique trading approach to help you along your trading journey.

Learn More

Maurice Kenny has helped over 600 people become financially free through one-on-one coaching, mentorship, and options trading strategy. Many of these new traders are now full-time traders, and they all started by watching his 1-hr webinar.

Feel free to check out other FREE educational resources to help guide you as you begin your new journey to financial freedom.

Also, download a (FREE E-BOOK) by Maurice Kenny, “DAY TRADE LIKE A MILLIONAIRE.”